Catalans Dragons 32 Hull KR 24, Errors and Discipline Cost Robins Dear Despite Brave Display

Hull KR were left ruing costly errors and poor discipline as they slipped to their second consecutive defeat in Super League and slipped out of the top 8 as a result.

With a game in hand on most of the teams above them after their involvement in the Challenge Cup last weekend there is no need for the robins to panic yet, what will cause concern is that they conceded 30 points for the second game in a row.

Jason Baitieri started the scoring for the home side after 7 minutes as the video referee deemed he had got the ball on the line without a double movement, the goal by Thomas Bosc gave the home side a 6-0 lead.

The lead for Catalans lasted just six minutes as Maurice Blair shrugged off three would-be tacklers and crashed in wide on the left, Josh Mantellato added the conversion from wide out to level the scores.

The game was fast becoming aggressive as both sides wrestled to take control, on the 19th minute Mantellato added a penalty to give the visitors a deserved 6-8 lead.

Albert Kelly pounced on a wayward pass and raced away from inside his own half but he was brilliantly chased down and tackled by Dragons full-back Morgan Escare which caused Kelly to lose the ball agonisingly short of the Catalans line.

Ben Cockayne got on the end of some fast cross field passing to stretch Rovers lead after 25 minutes, Mantellato hit the post with the touchline conversion attempt to leave the robins 6-12 ahead.

Just five minutes later Catalans marched down to the other end with the help of another penalty and Gadwin Springer crossed next to the posts to score in his second game for the Dragons, the conversion from Bosc brought the score level at 12-12.

Just 4 minutes before half time Catalans took the lead again as Todd Carney moved sideways across the Rovers defence and produced a pass to Michael Oldfield who touched down in the corner, Bosc hit the post with the resultant touchline conversion which left the Dragons with a four point lead at half time.

Half Time: Catalans Dragons 16 Hull KR 12

Rovers started the second half in profligate mood inviting pressure on their own line and, after just three minutes of the half, Eloi Pelissier pounced to score under the posts, the goal from Bosc gave the Dragons a 10 point lead.

Both sides kept trading possession as several dropped passes resulting in play see-sawing from one end to the other.

Kieran Dixon was lucky not to get 10 minutes in the sin bin after a blatant foul on Bosc as the French international knocked on.

Eventually Rovers took control of the possession they got and Kevin Larroyer, playing against what is technically his parent club, made a break down the left before handing on to the supporting Dixon who raced in under the posts to put the visitors back within striking distance, the conversion from Mantellato made it 22-18.

On 54 minutes Todd Carney created another try as he was allowed to offload in the tackle and Benjamin Garcia skipped his way over, the video referee overturned referee Richard Silverwood’s onfield decision to award the try, Bosc added the extras to stretch the home sides advantage to 10 points again.

More indiscipline followed as both sides seemed intent on winding each other up rather than trying to score points.

Elliott Whitehead finally took hold of the game by the scruff of the neck on 69 minutes and scored the home sides final try, Bosc missed the conversion to leave the Dragons leading 32-18.

With two minutes left Mantellato was awarded a try in the corner by the video ref and then kicked a majestic conversion from the touchline but it was too little too late.

In the final analysis this is a game the robins could, maybe should, have won and indeed they probably would have if it wasn’t for such poor discipline. The biggest concern though for coach Chris Chester may be that old defensive frailties seem to rearing their head again just ahead of trips to play Wigan Warriors in league and cup and a visit to table-topping Leeds Rhinos.

Final Score Catalans Dragons 32 Hull KR 24

Man of the Match: Kieran Dixon

Advertisements

Hull FC 4 Huddersfield Giants 24, Coach Radford Left Seething At Team As Three Match Winning Run Halted

It’s a theme that has been all too prevalent in a stuttering season so far from Hull FC and once again the old failings reared their ugly head at the KC Stadium last night as Hull were left in 11th place in Super League.

In the build up throughout the week to this game coach Lee Radford had put great emphasis on the importance of this game for the Airlie Birds season, but ultimately he, and the fans, were badly let down by a limp performance from the players.

The big news for Hull was the return to the starting line-up of half back Marc Sneyd after a month out with an ankle injury that he picked up in the defeat at Castleford.

Former Hull player Danny Brough started the scoring in the 10th minute when he was invited to run into a gap from less than 10 meters out and he scampered in to touchdown, the 2013 Man of Steel added the extras and the Giants held a 0-6 lead.

Hull kept testing the visitors defence and should have had a penalty try when Jamie Shaul was poleaxed by a head high tackle from Craig Huby as the full-back was crossing the Giants line but, instead of giving the penalty try referee Ben Thaler decided to just give the home side a penalty and sent Huby to the sin bin for 10 minutes.

Shortly afterwards Tom Lineham appeared to get over in the corner to score but the try was controversially ruled out by the touch judge who said he was pushed into touch.

After this the 12 men of Huddersfield marched down to the other end and Ukuma Ta’ai waltzed in to give them a 10 point lead although Danny Brough missed what should have been a simple conversion.

Just before half time another former Hull player Jamie Ellis also came back to haunt them as Steve Michaels made a hash of a kick behind his own line and Ellis pounced on the loose ball to score, another goal from Brough gave the Giants a convincing 0-16 lead at half time as referee Thaler was booed off the pitch.

Half Time Hull FC 0 Huddersfield Giants 16

The home side started with more energy in the 2nd half and a greater sense of urgency but too many silly mistakes and stupid penalties given away ultimately squeezed them out of the game and the Giants comfortably took control after a frantic opening 10 minutes to the half.

After 58 minutes Michael Lawrence finished the game as he strolled through a paper thin defence and, although Brough missed another simple conversion, the Giants led 0-20 and thoughts were clearly turning to Huddersfield inflicting the same ignominy of being nilled at home on the team who did just that to them in February.

After 65 minutes Hull finally showed some invention as Fetuli Talanoa made a break down the right, he was supported by Lineham and, as they traded passes, the Giants defence finally stopped them. With the opposition defence at sixes and sevens for the first time Hull swept the ball left and finally Kirk Yeaman flicked the ball out and Michaels ensured Hull would not be held to nil as he slid in at the corner, Sneyd missed the touchline conversion to leave the score at 4-20.

To add insult to injury Jermaine McGillvary added another try on the final hooter, Brough missed the touchline conversion leaving the final score 4-24.

In the press conference afterwards Hull coach Lee Radford said, “We are not a good enough side that we can afford six or seven blokes to toss in a performance like that and expect to come away with a result.

“Six times we got down their end in the first half and in the second half the few opportunities we had we didn’t take, but for six or seven blokes to throw in that effort and those errors doesn’t win you any rugby league game.”

Hull’s almost non existent attack is clearly a massive problem as the Airlie Birds are now the lowest scorers in Super League and that was just magnified by a very well drilled defensive performance from Huddersfield.

Radford went on to say, “I expected a performance out of the players because of the magnitude of the game and the need for a result, but individual poor performances cost us,”

A performance like this means next Friday’s home game against Salford Red Devils takes on extra significance for all concerned with Hull FC, a misfiring attack clearly needs to be worked on drastically and, against an injury ravaged Salford side, nothing but a big win will be acceptable for fans, coaches and team alike.

Final Score Hull FC 4 Huddersfield Giants 24

Attendance 9,930

Man of the Match: Mickey Paea